Argentina challenges Spain's biofuel rules at WTO
15/06/2012 75GENEVA, June 13 (Reuters) - Argentina said on Wednesday it was challenging Spain to explain a new biodiesel law that it says breaks World Trade Organization rules and could cost the South American country $1 billion in lost export earnings.
Spain's law came into force in April, and Argentine officials say it restricts biodiesel imports from overseas, barring major suppliers such as Argentina and Indonesia.
The challenge, which Argentina plans to make at a meeting of the WTO's Goods Council on June 22, will worsen its trade relations with the European Union, which filed a complaint last month over the country's trade restrictions.
Argentina's government called the Spanish law "protectionist" and said it "aimed to remove Argentina and other providers from the Spanish biodiesel market."
"Argentina is evaluating the possibility of taking this issue to a the WTO's Dispute Settlement Body," the Foreign Ministry said in a statement.
The EU's suit against Argentina followed a decision by President Cristina Fernandez to seize control of Argentina's biggest oil firm, YPF, a subsidiary of Spain's Repsol, in April.
The EU and Argentina plan to hold a first round of talks to try to resolve their dispute around July 12-13. If the talks fail to satisfy the EU, it could ask the WTO to set up a panel to adjudicate on the dispute.
The United States and Japan, which are among the countries that have asked to be third-party observers in the dispute, are also unhappy with Argentina's import restrictions and both plan to raise the issue at the Goods Council meeting.
That will prolong the war of words over Argentina's alleged protectionism and might be a prelude to more countries joining the EU in its litigation against Argentina.
"Last year we exported $1 billion of biodiesel to Spain, which was 20-30 percent of our total exports to Spain," an Argentine trade official said.
He said Argentina was talking to Indonesia and other WTO members who also opposed the Spanish directive, but it was too early to say if the challenge might lead to litigation and the EU had not yet responded to the criticism of the Spanish law.
Argentina is also critical of a judgment by the European Court of Justice on Sept. 6, 2011, which restricts imports of honey containing genetically modified material from corn produced with Monsanto's MON810 gene.
The EU, as a single trading bloc, represents Spanish interests in WTO disputes.
June 13, 2012
Source: Reuters
- Viet Nam’s trade surplus with EU expands amid economic headwinds
- Steel, cement and electricity firms to trade emissions quotas under Viet Nam's carbon market
- VCCI proposes 11 recommendations to quantify support for SMEs
- Trump’s copper tariff decision hangs over global metal market
- Global capital sees potential in Europe but calls for lighter regulation
